Appleby Film Club, 14th February
This film divided opinion among our Film Club members. It’s classed as a ‘romantic comedy drama’ and it is standard mainstream fare. Most people enjoyed it, but it’s not everyone’s cup of tea. I found it funny, light, and worth watching for wonderful performances from Meryl Streep, Emily Blunt and Stanley Tucci. Streep’s role, in particular, as the despotic editor in chief of a top fashion magazine, could easily have become an obvious Cruella de Ville-style cliché in the hands of a lesser actor. Streep pulls it off with grace and just the right amount of sympathy to create a real human character. Anne Hathaway plays the main protagonist with much less depth and a very predictable path through to a standard Hollywood ending.
The audience’s main criticism was the lack of surprise in the primary plot. The sub-plots around Tucci and Blunt’s characters were much more interesting. When these two and Streep were off-screen, particularly in the second half of the film, the action dragged.
Next Month: The highly successful and critically acclaimed Volver, directed by Pedro Almodovar. This is another comedy drama but a complete contrast to The Devil Wears Prada. It is R rated for sexual content, and sub-titled. No doubt it will also divide opinion!